7 Best Horror Sequels to Add to Your Halloween Movie List

Every year, as the air turns crisp and pumpkins begin to appear on doorsteps, horror fans around the world start planning their ultimate Halloween movie marathon. Whether you’re hosting a spooky movie night with friends or spending a chilling evening alone under the blankets, the right selection of Halloween movies can make all the difference. Halloween 2025 is shaping up to be an exciting season for horror lovers, thanks to a wave of sequels to iconic horror films that are hitting theaters or streaming platforms this year. These sequels not only bring back beloved (and feared) horror movie characters, but also push their stories into terrifying new territory. In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the most anticipated horror sequels of 2025 that deserve a top spot on your Halloween 2025 movie list.

The Conjuring: Last Rites (Warner Bros.)

Returning to the big screen this fall, “The Conjuring: Last Rites” is the final chapter in the saga of Ed and Lorraine Warren. After over a decade of demonic hauntings, cursed objects, and malevolent spirits, this Halloween movie promises to close the book with a truly terrifying case. This time, the Warrens are called to the Vatican to investigate a string of possessions linked to a mysterious manuscript dating back to the 1400s. What begins as a religious investigation turns into a deeply personal journey for Lorraine, as her psychic abilities begin to unravel a horrifying truth. With Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga reprising their roles, fans of horror movie characters steeped in supernatural lore won’t want to miss this.

Terrifier 3 (Dark Age Cinema/Bloody Disgusting)

Art the Clown returns once again in this blood-soaked follow-up to “Terrifier 2.” Known for its extreme gore and over-the-top practical effects, the Terrifier franchise has become a cult favorite among fans of slasher horror. In “Terrifier 3,” the story unfolds on Christmas Eve—a unique twist for a Halloween movie list, but trust us, it belongs there. After disappearing at the end of the previous film, Art resurfaces in a small snowy town where he embarks on his most sadistic killing spree yet. The film dives deeper into Art’s origins, hinting at a supernatural force that keeps reviving him. For those who like their Halloween movies filled with mayhem, cruelty, and gallons of fake blood, this is a must-watch.

Smile 2 (Paramount Pictures)

“Smile” became a viral horror hit in 2022 thanks to its disturbing imagery and unsettling concept. In 2025, the sequel “Smile 2” continues the legacy of the cursed smile—a supernatural entity that feeds on trauma and manifests through eerie grins. The new protagonist, a journalist investigating mass hysteria linked to smiling victims, begins to unravel a horrifying pattern that ties global incidents together. The tension is psychological, the visuals deeply haunting, and the scares are layered with social commentary on mental health and grief. Smile 2 doesn’t just repeat the formula; it expands the mythology and dives even deeper into the cursed chain of death. If you’re curating a Halloween 2025 horror marathon that leans toward psychological horror, this film will fit right in.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 (Universal/Blumhouse)

Following the financial success of the 2023 adaptation, Blumhouse has returned with “Five Nights at Freddy’s 2.” This time, the story takes us to a sister location of Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza, introducing new animatronic monsters and a darker backstory involving the original night guards. For fans of video game-based horror, this sequel adds lore from later entries in the game series and brings to life even more terrifying versions of fan-favorite characters like Foxy, Springtrap, and Balloon Boy. While the first movie had its critics, it built a loyal fanbase that’s eager for more—and this entry delivers higher stakes, better pacing, and scarier jump scares. A great Halloween movie choice for horror movie characters that lean into both nostalgia and terror.

The Black Phone 2 (Universal Pictures)

Ethan Hawke’s chilling portrayal of “The Grabber” in The Black Phone left audiences shaken, and in 2025, the story returns with “Beyond the Static.” This sequel focuses on a new protagonist—a teenager who begins receiving messages from the spirit of one of The Grabber’s early victims. As he investigates, he discovers a hidden network of psychic children who once communicated through the black phone. This time, the supernatural element takes center stage, exploring a larger universe of cursed technology and unresolved hauntings. Atmospheric, eerie, and deeply human, this Halloween movie taps into themes of survival, grief, and vengeance. It’s perfect for viewers looking for something more emotional without sacrificing suspense.

The Nun 3 (New Line Cinema)

Valak, the demonic nun, returns once again to terrify audiences in “The Nun 3.” Taking place in Eastern Europe during the Cold War, the film follows Sister Irene as she investigates a monastery where the line between miracles and possession has been blurred. With the stakes higher than ever and a storyline that delves into ancient Christian mysticism, this sequel brings back the atmospheric dread that made the first film so memorable. Part of the larger Conjuring universe, it ties into “Last Rites” and might be the last chronological entry. If you’re assembling a Halloween movie binge centered on religious horror, this film delivers both scares and substance.

Hocus Pocus 3 (Disney+)

Not a horror movie, but for those who love their Halloween movies with a mix of magic, mischief, and just the right amount of spooky fun, “Hocus Pocus 3” is one of the most anticipated releases for Halloween 2025. The iconic Sanderson Sisters—Winifred, Sarah, and Mary—may have been vanquished once again in the last film, but magic, as always, finds a way. Following the post-credit teaser of a second Black Flame Candle, this third installment promises the return of fan-favorite horror movie characters with a new generation of witches discovering their powers and responsibilities.

While plot details are tightly under wraps, rumors suggest a more prominent role for Becca, the young witch introduced in part two, along with the mysterious Mother Witch, expanding the magical lore and themes of sisterhood, legacy, and temptation. Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy have all expressed interest in returning, and Disney has officially confirmed the film is in development for a Halloween 2025 release on Disney+. Blending humor, heart, and Halloween tradition, “Hocus Pocus 3” is a must-add to any Halloween 2025 movie marathon. It may not be a blood-curdling horror fest, but its legacy as a Halloween movie classic and its magical atmosphere make it perfect for viewers of all ages who still want a little bit of darkness with their candy corn.

Final Thoughts: Build the Ultimate Halloween 2025 Movie List

With such a rich selection of horror sequels in 2025, Halloween movie planning has never been easier—or more terrifying. Whether you love supernatural hauntings, slashers, possession stories, or psychological thrillers, this year’s lineup has something for every kind of fear. More than just entertainment, these Halloween movies continue the legacy of beloved horror movie characters while introducing fresh nightmares for a new generation. For Halloween 2025, consider mixing your movie marathon with both old favorites and these new sequels to fully capture the spirit of the season. So dim the lights, grab some candy, invite your bravest friends over, and press play. The screams of October await you.