9 Unpopular Opinions About Halloween That Might Get Anyone Boo-ed Off the Internet

Halloween is supposed to be the one night a year when ghosts, goblins, and gory clowns are welcome to roam suburban streets without anyone calling the cops. But somewhere between ancient Celtic rituals and Spirit Halloween stores popping up in every abandoned Toys “R” Us, the holiday has become… let’s say complicated.

While most people gush about how it’s the “best holiday ever” and how nothing beats the thrill of free candy and spooky vibes, there are opinions out there that refuse to play along. They’re not popular, they’re not polite, and they definitely wouldn’t win the neighborhood costume contest—but they exist, and they deserve to be heard. Here are 9 unpopular opinions about Halloween that might get anyone boo-ed off the internet.

Halloween Is Basically Corporate Christmas in a Black Cape

Remember when Halloween was about kids running around with pillowcases, begging strangers for sugar? Now it’s basically a second Christmas—just darker and stickier. Every store is lined with overpriced decorations by August. Pumpkin-shaped candles? $30. A plastic skeleton? $120. Glow-in-the-dark lawn inflatables? Don’t even ask.

The kicker? All of this goes on clearance for 90% off on November 1st. Which makes the scariest part of Halloween not the ghosts, but the way consumers keep falling for marketing campaigns.

Unpopular opinion: Halloween has stopped being about imagination and turned into a giant seasonal shopping cart.

Costumes Are Just Laziness in Fabric Form

Most Halloween costumes aren’t creative—they’re lazy. “Sexy nurse.” “Sexy cat.” “Sexy pumpkin latte.” It’s basically lingerie with cat ears. Confidence is admirable, but creativity clearly took the night off.

Meanwhile, kids face the opposite problem. Parents squeeze them into costumes so elaborate they can barely breathe. A three-year-old doesn’t need to be a full-scale Darth Vader with a voice-changing helmet. They just want candy.

Once upon a time, costumes were homemade disasters. A bedsheet with two holes. Cardboard armor. Tin foil “alien antennas.” They looked ridiculous, but at least they had soul.

Trick-or-Treating Is Outdated (There, It’s Said)

Sending children door-to-door asking strangers for food? In 2025, when most adults don’t even want to answer the door for delivery drivers, such Halloween activity feels… archaic.

And it’s no longer the simple ritual it used to be. Parents now inspect every single candy bar like forensic scientists, terrified of “razor blades in apples” (which, by the way, has never actually been a thing). Some houses hand out toothbrushes, raisins, or gluten-free organic kale chips, which should honestly be classified as crimes against humanity.

Unpopular opinion: Trick-or-treating is less about joy and more about sugar negotiations between exhausted parents and hyper kids.

Halloween Parties Are Just Excuses to Drink in a Wig

Halloween parties all follow the same script. A living room is decorated with fake cobwebs, half the people wear last-minute costumes (“I’m a vampire, see the teeth?”), and the other half use Halloween as an excuse to dress in fishnets and get wasted.

By the end of the night, the fake blood is smeared, the plastic pitchfork is broken, and someone has lost their devil horns in the bathroom. It’s basically New Year’s Eve with more glitter and less dignity.

Unpopular opinion: Halloween parties are overrated unless you’re seven years old and hopped up on Milky Ways.

Pumpkins Are the Overachievers of Produce

Carving pumpkins sounds cute until reality hits. Forty-five minutes are spent scooping out slimy orange guts that smell like regret. Then come the dull knives and shaky hands, resulting in a lopsided face that looks less like a spooky ghoul and more like a depressed potato.

And then there’s pumpkin spice. Starbucks managed to turn pumpkins into a personality trait. People proudly declare themselves “pumpkin spice girls,” and the internet just nods along.

Unpopular opinion: Pumpkins are trying too hard. Apples are the real fall MVP.

Halloween Isn’t That Scary Anymore

Halloween has lost its edge. Horror movies are streaming all year long, haunted houses feel more like interactive theater than genuine fear, and costumes have become more “aww” than “ahhh.” A toddler dressed as a baby bat is adorable, not terrifying.

Honestly, the scariest thing about Halloween these days is Uber surge pricing after a party.

Cultural Clashes Make Halloween Weird Abroad

In countries where Halloween isn’t traditionally celebrated, things can get… awkward. Decorations pop up in malls, but there’s no real cultural connection. It’s like watching someone cosplay a character they’ve never heard of.

Parties are thrown without context, and trick-or-treating sometimes means kids wandering apartment complexes while confused neighbors hand out rice crackers.

Unpopular opinion: Halloween outside of its original cultural context feels like a bad reboot of a movie no one asked for.

Parents Use Halloween as a Social Media Flex

Every year, Instagram is flooded with toddlers dressed as avocados, baby Yodas, or tiny Taylor Swifts. Cute, yes, but let’s be honest: the kid didn’t pick that costume. Mom and Dad did—so they could farm likes.

It’s basically free marketing content disguised as childhood nostalgia. And while the pictures are adorable, the children are usually just trying to eat a Reese’s while wearing three pounds of face paint.

Unpopular opinion: Halloween for kids has become the holiday for parents’ Instagram feeds.

Candy Is Overrated

Halloween candy isn’t even that good. Half of it is the cheap stuff—rock-hard taffy bricks or candy corn that tastes like sweetened chalk.

Even the “good candy” loses its appeal quickly. A bucket of Snickers sounds exciting until it results in a week-long sugar coma.

Unpopular opinion: The best part about the candy is pawning it off on coworkers the next day.

Conclusion: The Grinch Wore Orange and Black

There’s no denying Halloween still holds some magic. A crisp October night, bonfire smoke drifting through the air, little kids running around in costumes—that part is pure joy.

But the holiday has become a mix of forced consumerism, lazy costumes, and social media bait. The folklore and creativity that once defined it now feel like they’re run by Target and Starbucks.

Maybe unpopular opinions are just reminders of what Halloween used to be: a holiday about imagination, storytelling, and community. Or maybe they’re just proof that not everyone is enchanted by fake cobwebs and fun-sized candy bars.

Either way, the conversation is worth having—because sometimes, the scariest part of Halloween is admitting it might not actually be that great.

Boo.